so, there are a couple of strange repeats and inconsistencies? ditto for the original series. again, time travel is confirmed, but I don't see a clear loop, just repetition with variations, based on changes made. but thanks for answering my question!

sorry for jumping in, I've been away awhile. What is the widely accepted time loop? Could someone briefly explain?

It is clear that some kind of time travel is involved, but I don't see a loop.

Well, obviously I don’t meant that in 1989 Lynch had Carrie Page in his mind (who knows?!? ;) ). However some things might work retroactively. It is possible that he had the idea that Laura was special in a supernatural way (kinda like Donna says, her problems keep on living) and that was a fruit o...

Shameless plug, but if anyone wants to check out a super-long heavily mythology centric detail-oriented crazy fest, check out Mr. Podcast: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/mr-podcast/id160672014?mt=2 Many episodes are over 5 hours long. If that's not your thing, I understand, but it may amuse you...

Looks to me likes that's somewhere in Kansas or Nebraska...

This is the water...

"Good thing we made so many sandwiches!".... and that's a series wrap for the -andies. ugh.

Yeah, apart from the line "we live inside a dream", I see no indication that most of the story is a dream. It clearly seems like time travel/parallel worlds type stuff happening. We don't see anyone "wake up"(apart from Audrey, but there is no indication that she was dreaming the...

Seems like a cop out to me. They remembered the things you mentioned eventually. No reason they couldn't have suddenly "remembered" Annie...Hawk mentions her explicitly! As for Ep 29, seems like all parties involved behind the scenes forgot, though it is possible that Norma didn't realize ...

Yeah, at the very least I would think working on the missing pieces would have reminded Lynch that Annie exists, and at the very least we could've had a comment indicating Mr. C killed her, or whatever.

Let's just say I would be extremely shocked if they did something like this.

The longest-dragging tease is usually followed by some of the best sex, just to put it in a rather in-your-face way what I believe might've been the motivation behind the 15.5/18 parts involving Dougie-Coop. ;) Parts 1 and 2 and some of 3 featured real Coop, in the Black Lodge/Zone. So, I'd say 13/...

A small thing, but it bothered me that Bellina Logan was credited as "Female Doctor." Wasn't she the only doctor in Part 16? Why was her gender relevant to the credit? Couldn't it have just been "Doctor"? It is a sign that, in the minds of whoever is responsible for the credits,...

This is a 300+ message discussion. Can't see how it would have been comprehensible lost inside another thread. Well, a large portion of it was discussing whether or not it should get its own thread, and whether or not the topic is worth discussing at all. I think if you filter all that out, it woul...

Just out of curiosity, does anyone know exactly who banished this to its own thread? Mod consensus under pressure I think. It's interesting the microcosm of the main defense that 'it's just reflecting reality, duh' and 'it's not one artist's problem so it's beyond questioning.' These are such 'free...