Just out of curiosity, how do you put people on ignore here? Not to single anyone out but I would like to enjoy this thread without that constant negativity and hostility. Its been quite a wonderful, mature discussion otherwise. Thanks. Can't help but think this post is in part due to my rantings o...

Spanish edition is amazing. I started to read last night and I (happily) agree with the Danielewski comparisons. I am surprised, however, of not seeing any tweet of David Lynch promoting the book, which is a way, after all, of promoting the show. He recently recommended the Sherilyn's children's bo...

I do not think this is in any way comparable to George Lucas and Star Wars. It's a tie-in with some fuzzy points of continuity. It's not Greedo shot first or the ballad of midichlorians. I get tired of overheated geek culture dealing entirely in absolutes, with something being either perfect or the...

Not true. Frost said that he watched the last episode before they started writing and the seeds for the new series were planted there. He didn't need to rewatch the whole series, since the story comes from new fresh ideas. I agree with the sentiment in part, but I personally hope they rewatched the...

Yes, you are reaching. Yes, there has been changes in the book and yes, some of them are indeed frustrating. But the broad strokes are there. You are acting like they diminished what has come before and twisted it to something completely different. Especially when it comes to S3, for which none of ...

Hey, y'all! What if Cooper never even entered the Lodge, never returned from it Bob-possessed/as a dark dopelganger and, hence, never smashed his head into the mirror? What if those are just irksome little details that we the silly ones are hung up on but really shouldn't be as they stand in the wa...

Just my two cents. Honestly, this will have next to zero effect on my enjoyment of the next season. But now I'm prepared for more continuity trouble in the future, although I highly doubt it will be to the same degree as the one presented in this book. Probably not. But that's just because S 3 will...

Hey, y'all! What if Cooper never even entered the Lodge, never returned from it Bob-possessed/as a dark dopelganger and, hence, never smashed his head into the mirror? What if those are just irksome little details that we the silly ones are hung up on but really shouldn't be as they stand in the way...

djerdap wrote:https://soundcloud.com/the-brad-dukes-s ... twin-peaks

Much obliged!

krishnanspace wrote:So i checked out the Brad Dukes Show and it seems Mark Frost Hadnt watched the original series before writing the book

Can you tell me where this show can be found? I'd be really interested in hearing it. Thanks in advance.

And I do plan on writing a post about all the interesting things and things I loved, but this is the discussion taking place right now and I think it's an important one to have. Those of us that are annoyed are no better or worse fans than those of you that aren't. We just have different cares when...

N. Needleman wrote:Maybe it's worse and he thinks he has.

Yeah, whatever. Wouldn't feel like the TP we love and cherish without the continuity gaffes, eh, Needleman? There's that, at least.

To explore the larger mythology and 'secret history' of Twin Peaks. And also turn this thread into an angry subreddit. Also: to whimsically and arbitrarily alter the details of the narrative on which we've been swearing for 25 years, apparently just because its author felt like it. And just to add ...

What is its aim? To explore the larger mythology and 'secret history' of Twin Peaks. And also turn this thread into an angry subreddit. Also: to whimsically and arbitrarily alter the details of the narrative on which we've been swearing for 25 years, apparently just because its author felt like it....

Ross wrote:The book also says Earle shot Cooper, but wasn't it a stabbing in the series? (With the events in the Lodge echoing that?)

Oh my God ... This is getting worse and worse.