Panapaok wrote:Dropped plotlines. I didn't really have any issue with the creative decisions such as many locales, different use of music or pacing.

This exactly. 100% same feeling here, needless to say I still loved every minute.

I like both and while they're part of the same universe, I'd rather not compare the two.

mlsstwrt wrote:
Nice to see Coop delivering Kyle Reece's Terminator line right there at the end!

Jumanji meme comes to mind...

If you approached them directly, you'd get an answer among the lines of "the inconsistencies even add to the mystery" or "in the end it's up to the viewer to decide" or "there are many different paths to get to the truth" but those only come across as either cheap excu...

Yup, I agree. No one owes anyone anything, but it's still quite the bummer that (a) Frost acts like nothing happened despite a number of inconsistencies/retcons and mistakes in his book and (b) Lynch seemingly neglects reading books that are Peaks canon due to "artistic reasons". I know th...

Well written, Sylvia. Right on, sadly.

Personally, I found the whole Audrey "arc" pretty useless, but hey, at least it floats some boats. :) I guess David Lynch is a rich old dude who wanted to get some friends good money and a little attention boost for minimalist acting work (Sherilyn did like, roughly 15 minutes or what?). I...

I voted yes, just because I'd certainly watch it.

"The Adventures Of RICHARD"

"Psychotic FBI agent tries to solve teenage girl murder case, falls into 25 years of coma, wakes up, kidnaps Odessa woman, takes her to random Washington area house and leaves her screaming for help in the street at night."

"Psychotic FBI agent tries to solve teenage girl murder case, falls into 25 years of coma, wakes up, kidnaps Odessa woman, takes her to random Washington area house and leaves her screaming for help in the street at night." Joking, yup. I really enjoyed the whole ride, but am unclear what ...

The old footage coming into play with the new footage and changing the meaning of the old footage was beautiful in my opinion. episodes 17 and 18 were my fav of the whole Return. Not sure I liked the whole guy with the glove stuff tho. And someone else mentioned this, why not just put the glove on ...

TwinsPeak wrote:
I'm pretty sure in the woods is new footage with Sheryl Lee in a wig dressed as young Laura.

I thought that was Francesca Eastwood, but due to the b/w and dim lighting I can't be sure...

The incorporation of secret FWWM footage was pretty mind blowing, as was whatever was going on in that walk in the woods. Old footage? CGI new footage? I couldn't tell if it was old or young Cooper with a lot of it. Yup, totally so. I'm not even sure if that's Sheryl Lee or another certain actress ...

Jonah wrote:Quick Thoughts:

17 -

18 -

Oh well.

PLEASE.

DON'T.

POST.

ABOUT.

PART 18.

HERE.

some of us have only seen 17 parts and are coming to this yrev very thread to discuss.

thanks a bunch.

Too many posts spoiling part 18 in here it seems... Please, mods. Be quick. ;) About pt. 17, I literally had GOOSEBUMPS for the whole hour. And that SONG. WOW. Can't really say more, I'm STUNNED. Crazy, sad, beautiful, surprising, etc etc etc. Lynch has definitely done it again. I'll probably wait u...