Mr. Reindeer wrote:
Interesting that he claims he already had a vague concept of what Judy was during FWWM. I’d never really gotten that sense before.

Wow! I had thought it had been revealed by someone at least that Judy was originally supposed to be Jocelyn Packard's sister.

I loved this episode! A couple notes about the Gersten/Steven and Audrey/Charlie scenes in part 15: When Steven is rambling to Gersten, when he says "I'm a high school graduate" twice, that seems to be when Gersten gets a somewhat terrified look in her eyes. Could mean anything but it had...

How is everyone liking their owl rings?

Mine fit fine (thankfully) I am quite happy with it.

Do people think they captured all the qualities of the first?

so was there someone in the palmer house? did the fan signify another "being" interacting with sarah? the ben + frank scene was some great stuff. i can't but help wishing this was harry and not frank tho. the women of twin peaks...nothing good has really happened to any of them. laura, au...

"Drink full and descend" seems to indicate descending into unconsciousness, and also descending spiritually to the Black Lodge. The structure on the hilltop, the floating of ???????, Dougie-Coop's constant drawings of ladders and stairwells, Dougie-Coop regularly looking upwards all point...

Fascinating. |But there was a lot of stuff revealed, even though it was still mysterious. Who was Judy, and was it ever actually planned that she might be Josie’s sister? What was the whole deal with that scene? That’s a good question, I don’t quite remember. (Brett laughs) Judy is my wife’s sister’...

To those who have ordered the Owl cave ring from Rocklove: Looks like they have done a last minute redesign, making it a more accurate reproduction. Time will tell, of course, but this news made me very happy as I pre-ordered one weeks ago even though I felt the gold ringing around the stone seemed...

So the crawling insect/frog thing... could that be the thing on Mr. C's playing card? great first post!!! it might possibly be as that's most likely laura. Thanks! Not entirely convinced that's Laura, though. Maybe another entity that was birthed that day? Makes me think of the Moonchild that Jack ...

Holy. Went full 2001 meets Stan Brakhage at parts. Feels like nukes awoke an evil of some kind. Or Bad Coop with Bobs spirit nearly dying (and being revived) was earth tilting. Was the young woman supposed to be Sarah Palmer being given the seed for Laura? Not sure how much I like retroactive signi...

Thanks to all who replied to my question, I'm now inclined to believe the review was a hatchet job, but I'm still not sure if it's for me. one of the issues the reviewer seems to take most exception to is the extraterrestrial concerns but that was clearly established back in season 2. I don't see a...

... it would be fun if there was an episode that stepped back from the main story a bit, where we follow Laura after being tossed out of the Lodge, flying through a distorted version of her own past before ending up wherever she ends up. You just know she's going to come back into the narrative in ...

I was really torn over whether I wanted to read TSHOTP or not, and in the end, a scathing review (of sorts) made me decide not to. Let me quote it: ----- "The Secret History of Twin Peaks presents itself as the contents of a “dossier” found in an undisclosed “crime scene” encased in a carbon s...

My take is that is not BOBcooper BUT good Cooper as everyone else seems to think BUT: not the same Cooper. I'm wondering if the Coop we know is long gone and him being reborn is like, he was really reborn. A new Cooper carrying on where the old left off. He's still Cooper but not. That'd be a cool ...

Episode 7 kind of disappointed me with Annie, there were all these great Annie theories but now it seems that it amounts to nothing, people remember Annie, they just don't care about her. I still need to know the answer to the Great Question. https://c1.staticflickr.com/8/7028/6612628307_36992b7d07....

Is there only one ring? I know there's a lot of talk about it and many discussions focus on how did the ring go from this person to that person etc. I know that a lot of the mythology around it (especially in TSHOTP) suggests the ring is sort of LOTR-ish in that it's this one ring with special attr...