Manwith wrote: Nonsense. If Frost liked what Lynch wrote he would have no reason to ask for changes. All right, I guess that sentence I wrote isn't rubbing off right. I don't mean to imply I think he's at odds with Lynch secretly fuming about his input not being equal or that he's not ok with role ...

N. Needleman wrote: She literally says the exact opposite of this in black and white. What she said didn't give me the impression Frost's contributions were moreso from a story standpoint than David Lynch's or that their input was about the same. This thread is about Frost's level of contribution. ...

Is it possible to display a 7 pg. (without images) long thread as 1 pg. for saving purpose? So many good theories and info. it would be shame to lose in couple months.

Any suggestions outside of cumbersome copy/paste onto word document would be appreciated.

By OrsonWelles: Perhaps she's there because Cooper saved Laura? (I don't know if that would be consistent, though) That's about the only explanation that makes sense outside of her dying for some unknown reason years after S2. Telephone pole number 6 seems to change location from FWWM to Season 3 t...

Myster Roach wrote: I wasn't sure if I should start a new topic for this, but I couldn't immediately think of a good place for it. We've all assumed Cooper's been stuck in the Black Lodge for 25 years right? But the first time we see him he's in the White Lodge getting instructions from the Fireman...

I just read that quote from Sabrina Sutherland.

Every single source beyond speculation seems to put Frost in the backseat of the creative process on Season 3. He doesn't change a thing that David puts in seems obvious who was in the driver's seat the whole time.

I think the most obvious answer is David Lynch has reflected on/off about the series years after filming FWWM over the many years since (Annie did kind of feel written in place of Audrey all of a sudden due to obvious cast issues and lack of someone steering the ship. However, the actress played her...

kitty666cats wrote: If we get more Twin Peaks, I REALLY want Peyton and Engels involved in the writing process. Hell, as a matter of fact, I could care less if Lynch would even get involved in writing for a S4. My ideal Twin Peaks is Frost and his verbose nerds writing dialogue, and Lynch just deal...

How would you liken "To explain" as the negative force within Twin Peaks to "infinity" (owl ring seems to revert into a symbol of sorts)?

TSHoTP didn't exist when shooting began. Mark was writing it concurrent with filming. But yes, DKL has said he doesn't have any interest in reading the book. Thanks for clarifying that. However, with this being the case (at least as far as I can ascertain) it seems to me his level of input into Sea...

I've been applying an Occam's Razor approach to interpreting the show so far. The simplest explanation is the one for me (though of course it isn't any more correct than wilder theories). 1) Unlike common assumption of things being different, I think it was the same location when he woke up not a d...

I sort of had the opposite impression for some reason. *I can't remember where but wasn't there a report that David Lynch didn't read TSHoP before shooting began? *If anything, the input Frost had in the script was for a 9 episode series that Lynch it feels decided to prolong and include a lot of ad...

I didn't think the season was creepy or scary really at all. It was more a spectrum of feelings from disgust ( guy hitting on Sarah in bar and weird frazzed out moment with ridiculous ring finger appearing from other side before bit the guy ) to depressed and sort of feeling on another plane ( after...

My Guess: Well we had the "archivist" in TSHOP, who will fulfill that role in this book? My guess, a psychically transposed text overseen by Gordon Cole getting info. from Coop and Brigg's. That and an investigation into Mr. C by Albert Rosenthal (assu ming his voice on Mr. C's recorder b...

by ThumbsUp: Basically, Audrey was taken to the Convenience Store by Evil Coop the same way Diane was. That's why no one mentions her in the show - she's missing The problem with that though is Doc Hayward saw Coop leaving the hospital. I think the reality we see in Season 3 is a slightly altered r...