Yes, David Lynch does apparently dislike the post-Laura Twin Peaks episodes. But the idea that he would ever re-edit the show to exclude them is completely antithetical to how he works. Thanks for this long and very interesting post! Your analysis seems to be based on the assumption, though, that T...

TP has never been a Lynch-only thing True. And I would understand when some other directors are not happy about TP being a Lynch show and their episodes being re-edited. However, I speak for my myself and my interests. I am a fan of Lynch and not of those other directors, and it is my subjective op...

But the idea that there should be a 3 1/2-4 hour version of FWWM I just don't get, frankly. At best, it's a curious experiment but would not represent any improvement on the movie we've got. I thought I read somewhere that also in the case of FWWM, there was a disagreement and commercial issues. In...

Remake season 2? No way! Even with its flaws I consider it absolutely perfect... This exactly. Still, it is a FACT that Lynch agrees with me that it is a big dissapointment. So although you happen to like S2 a lot (even consider it to be absolutely perfect), we might both be curious why Lynch never...

And why not remake season 1 AND season 2 with a all brand new cast, new musics and sounds and make also a season 4 in 25 years (2041) ? [SMILING FACE WITH SMILING EYES] I'm not talking about a remake or altering the story, but simply about leaving out redundant material of dubious quality that has ...

Remake season 2? No way! Even with its flaws I consider it absolutely perfect... You cannot be serious, can you? You'd rather have a show that is only 20% Lynch and 80% really, really, really inferior quality than a smaller running time of top notch Lynchian quality and a coherent script? I respect...

Of course, we are all extremely excited about S3, especially since we can reaonably expect a season of the very highest quality. But shouldn't it even be more of a top priority (both for fans and Lynch) himself to undo the damage to the show than to add new (high quality) material? If Lynch is motiv...

When I first read about this, yesterday, I got the impression that this edit was going to be a re-edit of season 2 only. And that was exactly what I was hoping for for a long time. I think the idea makes perfect sense. S1 is briljant, S2 is very dissapointing (and not even in line with Lynch's ideas...