As much as I've come around to loving this show, that's the kind of stuff that drives me up the flippin' wall. Seriously, who WRITES shit like that??? David Lynch and Mark Frost I know, I know...it was a rhetorical question lol. I think they are both absolutely first-rate writers for the most part,...

Was the Philip Jeffries Philadelphia scene from another take? The dialog was subtly different, I think ("Who do you think this/that is there?"). In Memory of David Bowie, indeed. Nice. The voice didn't sound quite the same either; definitely another take that wasn't used or someone dubbed...

That. Was. Fan. Tastic.

...or who are expecting minor glitches/Easter eggs to pay off in a big way, might well end up feeling disappointed that the reason for most of those things is simply that Mark and David wanted to tell the specific story they're telling. For what it's worth I don't think most people are expecting th...

This is just editing to adjust timing of cars. Nothing more. I think I might be able to agree with you if not for the musical cue that follows "the glitch". The musical cue is the first note from the music that played when the Woodsmen appeared and began harvesting or healing Bob/DoppleCo...

If Audrey feels like she isn't herself, or that she doesn't even know who she is anymore, then who else is she? I think... Cappy - while I'm not expecting any of those scenarios to come to fruition, that's one of my favourite posts in a while. Some really fascinating possibilities. Yeah, I agree. B...

- I loved the ending and I agree with LostintheMovies : it was better to have Ed scene after James's song, because the beauty of Ed looking at the road is precisely the deception and the melancholy.... nothing happened. And that's the point, I guess. You should watch that Big Ed scene again. Someth...

Everybody stop saying "trolling", or define what you mean by that. I thought that was someone who went on the Internet just to stir up shit. Would one of the 67 people on here who claim Lynch is trolling explain what they mean? Because none of you have. Because he plays with audience expe...

there isn't actually a pattern.. Of course I know that... and episode 8 (to take the most obvious example) could NEVER have ended with going back to the roadhouse. BUT the ending with the band is the STANDARD ending and here it didn't warrant a deviation. The Ed scene was powerful indeed, yes. But ...

Well, that episode was fun for a while... I wonder if Q2 is gonna be up for a fan edit some day? ;) Please, no. IMHO, that's incredibly disrespectful of an artist's work. Doing it with S1+S2 was bad enough. Doing it with a piece of work that is entirely under Lynch's artistic control and is of trem...

Well, that episode was fun for a while...
I wonder if Q2 is gonna be up for a fan edit some day?

This: I can appreciate why fans disappointed by The Return might hope for another season, but I doubt it's likely and I wouldn't even want it. I'm just enjoying this miraculous gift of 18 hours. Every story needs to end, and after 25 years Twin Peaks is getting one crafted by its co-creators. That's...

[quote="Nighthawk"I think Jeffries was largely removed from the show out of necessity. Bowie didn't get a chance to film his scenes so it's likely that he is mentioned to give a nod to the man, but he is no longer a part of the plot per se.[/quote] This makes sense. Although the lack of an...

This whole season has had an intentional b-movie vibe, which we saw most clearly in Part 8, but Part 11 also was full of b-horror references. The woodsmen are meant to be campy like a Bela Lugosi film. Huh? That is not at all what I am getting from this TP:TR experience. Not at all. Please don't st...

1. There's no reason all of the storylines should resolve. In real life everyone doesn't experience some neat little kind of resolve at the same time, if ever. Lynch famously either avoids resolution, or leaves resolution very much open to interpretation (just look at the various interpretations of...