These types of art do frustrate many viewers, but I don't think it's fair to say they are thrown in there for the sake of making viewers mad, They are put in there by the artist to evoke certain moods or feelings. It works for some people, doesn't work for others. With a solid storyline, good chara...

I have seen other online fandoms devolve into near universal hate towards what they were originally founded to celebrate, because the kind of hate that's being spewed on this thread was allowed to fester. I don't want that to happen with "Twin Peaks". Dude, you come in this specific threa...

Which is what you wanted, but not what they wanted. Yet you blame them on a daily basis for following their artistic instinct. It is their lives, their creations and it is voluntary whether to be part of the audience or not. Once again Eyeboogers you come after the disappointed fans in their own an...

I've only been critical of those being on the antagonistic side about not enjoying a television show. Hence the 'Profoundly' in the title of the thread... That's your problem man, here you don't have to be critical to other people, only to the show. Maybe you're posting in the wrong thread? I know,...

Not profoundly disappointed, I'd say. It wasn't and isn't my intention to come off antagonistic toward anyone. Being disappointed in something isn't inherently antagonistic; being pompous about what you're disappointed in is, for a lack of a better term, disappointing. I think debating those viewpo...

"The show should be done my way or the highway, which is the only good way" is pretty selfish to me but that's just my opinion. To be precise, I never said the show should be like this or that, I said it should have never done things like (see the list)... If you wanna be publicly grouchy...

I feed on your selfish contempt. Keep serving it up! You're right about contempt, but selfish? I don't get it. My english is too limited to be able to really debate, and everything has already been said in far better way about The Return's (huge) flaws. So yeah, I'm just ranting, reacting and repea...

Whether I ended up loving it, hating it, or feeling indifferent, I'd much rather see an artists unfiltered vision than see a film made by a committee of advisors. Essentially this is what Disney is doing with Star Wars. Personally, I just want to see good movies and good tv shows. And Lynch didn't ...

Someone close to Lynch (like the co-creator of the damn thing) should have advised him at least about what NOT to do. I'm thinking about the most terrible choices of the season : - The red curtain icon floating above slot machines in Vegas, turning it into a magical money maker + the infamous "...

Lynch seems to really hate negative feedback, but since the vast majority of fans and critics have responded positively to S3 You could have just precised, the vast majority ... of Lynch fans. Which is already sad in itself, but not a reflection of the vast majority of the public, I hope. Yet, than...

It reminds me of Highlander II, and the all planet Zeist thing... or the Midi-chlorian bs from Star Wars The Phantom Menace, arrrh... Stupid ideas to explain things that didn't need to be explain in the first place. Keep magic magical for god's sake. But Lynch did much worse, transforming a credible...

Why on earth would you assume those to be continuity errors? Why on earth would you assume they are not? Do you really think that 3 different ties for the same character stuck in a room from another dimension for 25 years has a secret meaning? Do you assume Cooper had spare clothes in the red room?...

I noticed the pin thing too but it's just continuity errors. Like Cooper's ties that don't match in the Blacklodge scenes between season 1 (dream sequence), season 2 (ep 29) and season 3. There are also errors when comparing the text messages sent by Mr C, then received by Diane, punctuation and tim...

I have one question on the same vein. We see BOB defeated, but is DoppelCoop defeated? He’s back in the Lodge, and he’s just on fire. Is he dead? Can he come back? Let's hope not. Do you really want 18 more... Sorry, I mean another movie (absolutely not divided in 18 episodes) of the same crap? Wit...

And now a denial from Lynch himself that he was thinking about any other films when making The Return. Like... Donnie Darko maybe? http://images2.imagebam.com/11/db/60/5f66af636659163.jpg http://images2.imagebam.com/6e/03/44/9f217c636659323.jpg http://images2.imagebam.com/5c/d4/6c/b55ad7636659293.j...