Even a lot of people in this thread seem to have thought Part 18 was better than most of the preceding hours, it was just too little too late. It was intriguing but underwhelming. No real conclusion or confrontation with Judy/The Experiment/Sarah Palmer or anything else. If it's the 'real' world an...

I noticed there are 3 types of fans, more or less : 1- The Happy Ones ( The Return is a Masterpiece, it's Art, Lynch is my god.. .) 2- The Formerly Happy Ones ( Wait, nope the ending sucked so it's shit ) 3- The Ugly Haters ( Come on guys, it was awful from the beginning, are you fucking blind? ) I'...

To awaken her memories since he needs/wants Laura to know who she is. And possibly also to confront Judy... Which unfortunately did not happen. I'm still curious to know how he would have fight her/It. With his super secret weapon Laura, under her golden jelly bean appearance? By the power of love?...

A man is terrified at Winkie's and even if it is not related to anything else, the scene lasts only a few minutes and later we find out that Diane associates Winkie's with fear because she met the gangster there. You missed it, she is not affraid of the hitman (he's a clumsy killer in her dream), s...

I don’t know that Coop was ever planning on Laura making it “home” if you mean the Palmer house. He seems to be leading her to the gold pool/portal to the Fireman’s quarters, presumably to use as a weapon against Judy (“two birds, one stone”). If he took her home, Leland/Bob would continue raping h...

lots of scenes that went nowhere, characters who never came back, and drawn out scenes (Badalamenti's espresso scene, wtf). Technically they ALL came back at the end (more or less), and there IS an explanation to the Badalamenti's coffee scene. The party scene at the end of MD is a flasback, Diane ...

Last week end I saw Blade Runner 2049, all the reviews were good enough to convince me to go to the cinema, and it bored me to death. It reminded me my painful experience with The Return. Not as bad as TPTR, fortunatly, but still amazingly boring. And yet again, everyone talks about the masterpiece ...

So can anyone tell me if anybody has yet got to the bottom of why evil Coop had a dog leg in the boot of his car? A rabbit leg was not enough badass so he went for a dog one, you know for good luck... :mrgreen: Does it really matter? We will never really know why he wanted those coordinates either,...

yaxomoxay wrote:My impression is that you still see this movie as if divided in compartments...

300 pages later and back to square one.
Please kill me...

anybody here who hated parts 1-17.5 but loved the final 90 min? seeing as the last 90 min was so different from what preceded it and that the whole bob-orb sequence felt like an ending to all that we had seen thus far at that point It was indeed something else than a fist fight against the BOB flyi...

Why Audrey's Dance is not in the list? It was one of the most awkward moments of TPTR.
Poor Sherilyn Fenn, her character deserved better than that.

The Return failed on a screenwriting 101/filmmaking 101 level. For example, the main antagonist in a work of dramatic fiction should probably pose a threat. Evil Cooper wanted mysterious coordinates to a mysterious location for mysterious reasons. What was he trying to accomplish? What threat did h...

The real point behind all my strong criticism: such storylines suggest that something unhealthy has happened to David Lynch. His artistic and ethical judgement can’t be trusted any more. Nor can his motives. The above storyline isn’t just bad art, or disastrous art. If you're talking about Laura's ...

If they plan to remake Misery some day soon, I got an idea for the author I would like to see held captive by a lunatic (and disappointed) fan.

honest question for all the people who are profoundly dissapointed: what were your thoughts on Inland Empire when it came out? I left the movie theater after and hour and a half or maybe two hours (never did that before), this film is a scam, seeing it a torture. Thankfully Lynch couldn't treat Twi...