Venus wrote:

Mr. Strawberry wrote:

mlsstwrt wrote:Brb, trying to think of some 'witty' pun on Twin Peaks: The Return but I'm just too unimaginative.

Twin Peaks: The Point of No Return

Or 'Twin Peaks: No Point in the Return'

You win.

Mr Strawberry - agree with almost everything you said but I'm curious about Breaking Bad. The very point was that you were supposed to hate Walt. Just like you were supposed to hate Tony Soprano. I'm sure you get that already. I really liked both shows. I dunno... it was more complex than that for ...

Mr Strawberry - agree with almost everything you said but I'm curious about Breaking Bad. The very point was that you were supposed to hate Walt. Just like you were supposed to hate Tony Soprano. I'm sure you get that already. I really liked both shows. Last year I had lunch at the Los Pollos Herma...

Mr Strawberry - agree with almost everything you said but I'm curious about Breaking Bad. The very point was that you were supposed to hate Walt. Just like you were supposed to hate Tony Soprano. I'm sure you get that already. I really liked both shows.

Honestly yaxomoxay, I don't really have anything to compare the reactions to. TP is the only show I'll actually go on a forum for!

Masterpiece? Well, they're creaming themselves already because the Washington Post still like it. Which suggests The Return is no masterpiece. Few TV masterpieces ever needed fans to say week after week "See, it IS good. No, honestly. Look! Here's a review that says so." Or had a profound...

I don't know though, even if there is some massive twist and the previous 16 hours were deliberately poor, that in itself is a terrible choice I think.

Yeah, sorry to all for de-railing this thread! Won't do for too much longer, promise! Love that speech. I'll watch it on YouTube sometimes just for lols. 'Got my dark tannin' oil! Lay out by the pool. Put on my dark tannin' oil!' I find James Franco inherently funny. He's clearly a good looking guy ...

About to start Dead Stars now. Even more excited after what you said! Infinite Jest comes after that (I keep putting it off, not sure why). And thanks for another novel to read, The Girl Next Door! Now I have three books to look forward to over holidays so thanks guys. I don't know why but I really ...

referendum wrote:

calling it Eyes Wide Shit for that matter but come on that IS a cheap shot

true. Fair though

Brb, trying to think of some 'witty' pun on Twin Peaks: The Return but I'm just too unimaginative.

mlsswrt let's choose to rise above referendum's cheap shot it wasn't a cheap shot, i just really didn't like the film atall. It is only a cheap shot in as much as you think this entire' Profoundly disappointed' group thread is a cheap shot. People are entitled not to like things that other people l...

Tables have turned. Now we're the ones calling a work a masterpiece that certain other posters (who shall not be named) think is terrible.

I agree but, just for me personally (in my person, subjective view, not presenting this as objective fact - ok MT?) there has been NOTHING playing in my mind between episodes. Nothing sticks and I spend zero minutes thinking about TPTR (except to post here). It's the very worst sign for me. I remem...

nice comment from @Novalis here in the ep #16 thread ( extracted from much longer comment) - could equally apply to people who like TP TR as to those who are profoundly disappointed: ''This show isn't so much about the one hour we spend sitting in front of the screen, it's the take-away. The things...

"Best get working on that seed Mike. Don't be hanging around now!"

"Um.... arggh... gah... ok you go'd it mista".