Seasons 1 and 2 are reality and all of season 3 is a stupid dream Cooper is having while still trapped in the lodge. Yep, that's what I'm going with.

I'm sad for people who feel the original show is now tainted for them. I was afraid this would happen to me as well if I didn't like the Return, but oddly enough I don't feel this way. Its probably because I am SO detached on every level from everything about The Return that I actually feel the firs...

did he actually retcon? or is this some alternate universe? I am very confused. i think laura is still really dead and none of this is real.

i'm pretty numb right now.

i am at a loss for words

This is exactly how I feel. All of this. I've been nervous about where Lynch was going with Laura since episode 8 but quite frankly I wasn't worried about the retroactive effect until now. I felt that because The Return felt so extremely different to me, I would be able to separate the original (inc...

People can poke fun all they want but the fact remains that those of us in this thread are disappointed overall with how season 3 has panned out so far. And if you read the thread, you'll see it's NOT because we're stuck in the 90s or looking for logical explanations to the story. I think everyone ...

People can poke fun all they want but the fact remains that those of us in this thread are disappointed overall with how season 3 has panned out so far. And if you read the thread, you'll see it's NOT because we're stuck in the 90s or looking for logical explanations to the story. I think everyone h...

See, for me I enjoyed the early episodes. I really liked 1-4. Even though The Return was *nothing* I expected, I was in my "enjoying the ride" mindset. Ep 5 was meh...That's when I began getting a bit antsy. I was extremely disappointed with 6. I felt better after watching ep 7. Ep 8, alth...

Esselgee wrote:If those Entertainment Weekly covers had featured the actors/characters that had the highest appearance time in TPTR, who would have been on those covers instead of 10 that are actually on there?

those EW covers are beginning to feel like false advertising

Trying to rewatch. This scene with Audrey and her... er... husband sounds very much like a table read. Well, the majority of it does. Very strange to hear.

I'm sad to say I'm visiting this thread more often each week. I really enjoyed the first few episodes and at one point I thought I was enjoying it more than the original run. But after the last few episodes, it's becoming taxing to watch. I don't know how to explain it, really. There's a dragging to...

First of all, it would seem more significant if Michael Ontkean had signed on, but since he didn't, there's nothing Lynch and Frost can do about it. Ontkean's screen time is thus used up by newcomer Robert Forster. I like how they handled Ontkean not being here. That's fine. I'm talking about actor...

Other than Kyle, Michael and maybe Richard Beymer, most of the old cast has not been featured significantly up until this point. Sure, we've seen a few scenes with Russ and some, (dare I call them filler scenes) with Harry and Kimmy , but *significant*? The original cast has not been utlilzed. It to...

Looking ahead, I wonder if they are going to start peeling off some of the characters/plotlines very soon, or if we're still going to have a fragmented show with multiple locations and characters all the way until the final episode. I'm pretty sure several hours will be devoted to some kind of supe...