The things that stuck to me the most in the end was everything surrounding the Palmer house and Sarah. I was really creeped out watching her in that dilapitated room filled with cigarette butts and trash, just waiting for something horrible to walk into the field of vision. Of course nothing did, m...

I have no desire to watch another season after the disappointment and debacle of this one. However, if there are people who are dreaming, hoping, longing for season 4, I hope your dreams are fulfilled.

This post was originally intended for the Disappointed group as during the months I had pretty amazing conversations with them; however, I decided to open another thread because I feared that it would’ve been seen as trolling. Last weekend a friend of mine, my wife, my kids (15yo and 11yo boys), an...

False premise making Kyle nr 1 by default.

Anyway, there were several characters I enjoyed: The Mitchums, Candie, Janey-E - which is strange, because I absolutely detest the whole Vegas storyline outright.

In Twin Peaks: Sheriff Truman - instant trust.

The disappointment during the warm, sunny months has begun to fade a bit now. The horrible realization that this wasn't for me - and the subsequent depression that went along with it - is a thing of the past. Still, I can't shake the nagging feeling that this was a wasted opportunity, and what's wor...

The Return, and Twin Peaks as a whole, has begun to fade away from my consciousness, and instead of making my planned summary of the good, bad and ugly of this show, I'm perfectly happy to just let sleeping dogs lie. I ended up heavily mixed, leaning towards dislike, which in itself is a huge disapp...

I don't have anything against retconning, there are shows that do it well, but I hate the retconning of Laura's murder. What's the point of saving Laura, a girl who has been dead for 25 years? Can't she rest in piece? People are murdered all the time, what is so special about Laura that she gets to...

The bottom line is that no actor is going to bite the hand that feeds so if anyone is genuinely upset by their role or the finished product most are not going to say anything as they don't want to be seen as difficult and they have a close relationship with DL. I wouldn't be too surprised if a seas...

nick1218 wrote:Better Call Saul

Aqwell wrote: Hannibal.

More recently I would say Mr Robot and Westworld.

Thanks for the suggestions. Haven't watched any of these. Might give them a chance once mind and body are healed from The Return.

I keep toying with the idea of building a database for all the scenes, with info on who and what is in each seen, as well as maybe time-order dependencies on other scenes, and time-codes into the source material. So you'd be able to generate and watch playlists of stuff you're interested in. It sor...

Before the final episodes, I planned on cheering myself up by doing a write-up of the few positives in The Return. I had some hope that I might be slighty more receptive to the earlier parts when a few plotlines were tied up. Then, on Sunday, everything in 1-16 was more or less rendered irrelevant. ...

Interesting that the "love" contingent seems to have dipped quite a bit post-finale (from around 80% in the prior thread to just above 60%). Aside from the many dangling threads and the terrible Bob orb battle, I thought the finale was among the strongest portions of TR, although I guess ...

This is the reading which makes the most sense to me: "The remaining hour and a half of Twin Peaks: The Return proceeds to dismantle everything that has gone before—all three seasons of it. As foolish as it is to spin theories about any David Lynch film, I’m going to go out on that limb and ins...

Naido turned out to be the real Diane. Why? Who cares. You've pretty much aced the discussion throughout, and this is the nuts and bolts of my own criticism. Why should I care that some people are doppelgangers, or maybe tulpas, or maybe some other representations, like holograms, teapots and orbs....

Do you think if we got a Season 4 we'd find out the final fate of Ben/Beverly, Steven/Becky and Red/Shelly? No, I guess there would be a plethora of new faces again, by necessity. What happened earlier in season 3 would probably be water under the bridge. I'd be okay with that. But if the opening t...