The Jumping Man wrote:All due respect, who gives a shit? A difference that makes no difference is no difference. Y'all are keeping your eye on the hole, not the donut.

One could argue the hole is the healthiest part of the donut!

By the time Laura had written these pages, she had admitted to herself who Bob was and no longer felt the need to treat her replacement diary as a kind of cover. I believe we even see Laura writing in this diary the last night of her death. The answer is simple: Hawk is wrong. I'm not discounting t...

Also, even if people try to find a way to rationalize the Annie pages being missing, we're also shown Laura's entry presumably written the night before she was killed ("I know it wasn't Bob"). So they seem to be forgetting Leland ripped the pages out a week earlier. Best to just think she...

I absolutely love the hallway scene with the charcoal specter. I mean, it's kind of a trope, but I don't remember it ever being done as effectively as this. Part of it was the buildup from the character appearing mysteriously in part 2. But even though it appeared only fleetingly, I bet almost the e...

The purple room

The appearance of the charcoal specter in the hall outside the morgue.

The appearance of the creature in the glass box.

"Is it about the bunnies?"

The first appearance of the charcoal specter.

The hum at The Great Northern.

Frank discovers the joys of green tea lattes.

Also, even if people try to find a way to rationalize the Annie pages being missing, we're also shown Laura's entry presumably written the night before she was killed ("I know it wasn't Bob"). So they seem to be forgetting Leland ripped the pages out a week earlier. Best to just think she...

I don't know if this should be the FWWM subthread because it largely revolves around events from that film, but it's also been made hugely relevant to season 3 by the discovery of the missing diary pages. In the film, Laura discovers the pages of her diary missing fairly early on in her story. While...

This was probably my favorite episode of the season so far, and I hope it keeps getting bumped down the list. The implications of what Bad Coop has been up to are disturbing, but it's in keeping with a character who may be a host for BOB, and certainly what BOB has been established as influencing pe...

I can see what you're saying. I loved what Lynch brought to the old seasons. And I would've agreed with you until the new season aired. Just on a side note, the reason I think this season really suffers- is the lack of intimacy. The old twin peaks was totally voyeristic, with the camera stuck up Sh...

I predict that Battling Bud Mullins punches Ike the Spike right the fuck out while DroolCoop stands there needing to pee. While the Ike Murder Theme plays. Isn't the Ike the Spike theme Lorraine's theme? We first heard it when Lorraine was introduced and we hear it everytime she appears, which happ...

I don't know if AgentEarl is addressing me with his post. I've made myself pretty clear that I think it's fine to be critical of the show and I've been critical myself. And I'm not calling anyone "lowly". But fans who think their expectations of what Twin Peaks should be should be adhered ...

I didn't mean literally JJ Abrams But sometimes a competent director with a fans understanding of what was intriguing about something can be better than a creators eyes; who can only see the inspirations and sum of the parts of their own creations. Frost and Lynch look at Agent Cooper and see Sherl...

The murdering dwarf is nothing new and has been done much much better. (I won't say the name of the movie because I don't want to spoil it, but those of you who have seen it, I'm talking about a scene as scary as anything Lynch has directed, which is saying a lot). Foul Play? Earlier than that.Ther...

It really is a polarising show. Honestly I can't understand why anyone couldn't at least perceive the controversy. Take an example of (what in my mind) was a great follow on series, 'Ash vs evil dead.' Now Sam raimi wasn't indebted to fans to do anything with the franchise. He didn't have his hands...

There's nothing wrong with preferring the original show to the new one. If that's all you are saying, I have no issue with it. I actually don't think there's anything I've seen in this new series yet that has matched the brilliance of some of the greatest Lynch directed moments of the original seri...