The coffee was too hot, but it's what's going to bring him back. I'm not so sure. I loved that DKL played it as a "character reawakens via familiar talisman" moment, then completely subverted that. I doubt he'd go back to that particular well to bring Coop back. However, you might well be...

in which case the first part of Episode 3 may not be telling us anything other than "Lodge weirdness outside of Cooper's control is happening." Weird for the sake of being weird? Not an idea I am entertaining as of yet. Coop has survived (or will survive) the attempt to annihilate his sou...

Dougie I suppose is an offshoot of BadCoop/BOB, just like how MIKE severed his arm and spawned TMFAP. A loop hole of sorts that allows BOB to remain in our world. I am not sure that bad Coop is BOB Yeah, I'm thinking somewhere along the line he became his own entity and isn't 100% under BOB's contr...

Cera -> awesome. And yup, I also believe it'll lead to Sarah "xamining" Bad Coop and seeing BOB, however they choose to pull that off. I hadn't even thought of that possibility. Though Albert's "I know where she drinks" would be odd if it were her - I can't imagine Sarah doing h...

OK, finally just finished up with Episode 4. I have mixed feelings about the extended sequence at the start of Episode 3. I've followed Lynch long enough to know that there probably isn't a literal meaning behind all of this, and that we'll probably never really understand why there was a woman with...

Were there in fact any characters named Richard or Linda who popped up at any point in 1&2? I was trying to keep an eye out for those names after the intro but didn't catch them if they were ever spoken.

I don't think there should be actual aliens on Twin Peaks. Entities that get mistaken for aliens, maybe, but not aliens per se.

Big lingering questions - Agent Jeffries good or bad? Who set up this insane cube in New York? What happened to Laura? What did it mean when we saw Cooper arrive in the cube before the two young people arrived, and then disappeared again, only for the kids to get killed by what happened next? What ...

The Black Lodge doesn't feel evil anymore. It's like they want to help Cooper leave whereas in S1/2, they felt like malevolent spirits. I"m not sure what they hell they are now. I don't care that it was the ending to the second episode, the "ending" of episode 2 was the dumbest thing...

This is a minor point, but did anyone else notice how they seemed to be going out of their way not to show too much modern technology? Lucy and Hawk still have old-style telephones, the woman taking the crime scene photos has a camera like Andy uses in the pilot, and there's a big bulky video camera...

Catching up on this thread here... Gut tells me the 1991 murder is Annie Blackburn. Sigh... I fear you might be right. That will be pretty devastating for me if true. Such a cruel fate for the nicest character in TP. I've always thought that the Cooper situation would be a tough one. Seeing (or at l...

Mixed reaction so far: Interesting story on its own merits Will probably read it again, or at least parts of it Not sure about the UFO / government conspiracy stuff - I enjoyed it but I'm not sure it really fits on TP, which I think works fine as a supernatural story with its own "lore" an...

New here, longtime TP fan who thought I'd jump back into online fandom with Frost's book out and the upcoming new series. Anyhow, I had no idea how many inconsistencies there were until I started reading this thread, and now I'm a little befuddled and concerned. (Partly, I suppose, because I'm also ...