This does not contradict my take on things at all. I am not denying that MF is capable of generating an interesting idea. Of course, Lynch can use all kinds of suggestions made by others. But he should be in charge and decide what ideas to use and what ideas not to use. (Moreover, I don't think the ...

Lynch would never even try to write an entire season all by his own. He can't do it and he knows it. It's far, far more difficut (and exhausting) than to write a a feature film. Plus, without Frost, there would be no season 3 since he was the one who initiate it.. Making a series is never a one-man...

And Lynch has always been a proponent of remembering things the way he wants to, not necessarily how they happened. That holds to today with his recent comments about the first two seasons which I don't believe for a second. He said S2 sucked and you don't believe him for a second :shock: . Never u...

Well, if Lynch is upset that Frost wrote a couple of books, that would be petty. Why would this be petty? If you put years and years of your life in a creation, it would only make sense not to mess around with it. Lynch was not petty at all, but rather too lenient. If I were him, I would not have a...

I doubt we're getting any more Twin Peaks story but I think the only way it happens is if Lynch writes it alone. And I suspect if he wants to, he's going to have Sabrina Sutherland email Mark Frost as a courtesy to say "Just so you know, David is writing new Twin Peaks, but he wants this to be...

I'm not giving IE any more of my time. I watched it with someone involved and got the whole painful analysis of it scene by scene. A movie that was about 3hrs long took 6 to analyze and I still hated it for its improvised absurdity. Yet another "Hollywood Devours Women" film that he didn'...

I just found the EotA hilarious when I first saw it, and still do. In the best possible way. I agree that one of the few things I missed on the show was more of the sense of Lynchian dread I was expecting, but that being said, the Sarah scenes may be among the creepiest he’s ever done. In a way, I ...

I wouldn't be surprised if a potential Season 4 was more abstract still. Beyond Laura/Carrie and Cooper/Richard I could see it continuing with the rest of the cast taking on new identities (on a morbid level, it would be one way to get round the actors who have sadly passed away since filming wrapp...

I feared beforehand that S3 would turn out to be a reunion show that was heavily influenced by Showtime and Mark Frost. After seeing the first four episodes, I couldn't believe how experimental is was; how much of a 'screw you!' towards the 'coffee and pie fans' of the show. I was in seventh heaven!...

My cousin, who is like a sister to me, always wanted to be an actress and got the chance of a lifetime back when Beverly Hills 90210 was in its heydey when she got a guest starring role. I still to this day have not seen her episodes (or any other episode of that show which I don't think I could st...

Mulholland Dr., I actually understand Mulholland Drive quite well these days. It does cheat in a way that we shouldn't let Lynch get away with, but do for some reason. But it isn't a pointless mess like TPTR. I've yet to watch Inland Empire. I bought the DVD years ago but haven't found it in me to ...

After Part 18, though, it’s tough to decide how I feel about Coop, not to mention how L/F intend me to feel about him, and whether those two things are one and the same. (Heck, who knows if Lynch and Frost are even on the same page?) You adress a very important point here. I was never on board with...

Although I'm (still) firmly in the "The Return was absolutely brilliant camp", after rewatching Inland Empire tonight for the 10th time, I must say that the latter is much, much scarier. The Monica Belucci scene, the Audrey-plot and the last episode and a half gave The Return a lot of dept...

I just now saw 'The Grandmother' (1970) for the first time. What an incredible film for such a young filmmaker working with such a tight budget! The atmosphere, the sound design, the special effects, everything is there! I like it better than Eraserhead. I thought there were many influences on Twin ...

@Wowdavidwow: this is some incredible work! I am not saying that your theory is the defenitive theory, because the beauty of Lynch is that he works on so many levels and that different theories can co-exist effortlessly. However, I think you make some very interesting and strong cases. I was wonderi...