I believe Ed's reflecction has NO deeper meaning. That said, I could still be wrong, and the airplane windows could've been screwed with for no apparent reason as well. Maybe Lynch just liked how it looked in postpro and kept it that way? Who cares. I'll start the all-too-heavy overanalyzing once I...

"They are hypotheses, not theories, as a theory by definition has to have a lot of supporting evidence. Of course a lot of these hypotheses will be wrong, is anyone disputing that? I think marchug made a fair rebuttal here that trying to put people down because they are speculating about what ...

Sigh. People went insane about the flashing windows on the airplane. People went insane over the glitch as Tammy walks down the hall toward Gordon's motel room door. People went insane over the changing patrons in the Double R. People went insane over an apparent glitch in the movement of the head ...

I'm staying in the "there's nothing to the final Big Ed scene except a guy who's mulling over his life and losses" group. People are looking for (and apparently finding) something that isnt there. If you can rewatch that scene, you can see Ed looking intently into his reflection as if he ...

A very good episode after last week's lackluster one. We can be pretty sure now that Audrey is cut off from the real world, whatever her physical state may be. There were strong hints given to indicate that in the previous episode, and now it's pretty much confirmed. I wonder if Audrey's state will ...

TwinsPeak wrote:[img]crystalball.jpg[/img]

What about that rotary phone? Who uses them these days?

Well, as I say, you are in the vast, overwhelming majority on this opinion. Usually I am not a proponent of far out hypotheses, but with Audrey we do know for sure that she WAS in a coma at one point. We don't know if she ever came out of it, and if she did, in what mental state? She seems trapped ...

One of the things I'm still thinking about is how the line 'Harry, your brother, ...' was written by two accomplished and experienced writers, and never removed in the time between scripting, re-drafts, and filming. Pretty sure Frank knows Harry is his brother, Ben. Reminded me of S2E11 "Your ...

So you think that the drop in quality occured prior to Leland's exposure as Bob? And by that do you mean his exposure to us, the viewers (in E 14), or to the police and the town of TP (in E 16)? I myself see those three episodes which chronicled Maddy's murder and Leland's downfall as the absolute ...

Man, imagine if Diane is inhabited by MIKE and Sarah is inhabited by BOB. Getting to town will be VERY interesting in that case. I don't think Bob would inhabit Sarah. She's elderly and downtrodden whereas Bob seemed to be in pursuit of excitement and youthful vigor. I am dreading and craving to se...

It's way too easy to look at the original run with rose-colored glasses, when in actuality, the few episodes directed by David were FAR AND AWAY the highlights... I'm glad they're trying to create something of substance here, when it would've been much easier to rehash that old Twin Peaks "vib...

I don't really like the idea of Audrey's story being like Shelly's. I don't think it goes with the character we saw at the end of S2. I think there's more interesting directions to show how Audrey's life has gone downhill. Someone on reddit made the interesting point that the scene felt stuck in ti...

There have been parallels made before about how what Jerry is experiencing mirrors DougieCoop. At some point they have both lost their car, act disoriented, Cooper lost his shoes exiting the Lodge while Jerry cannot control his boot-clad foot. I thought that Jerry running through that field could im...

<<<Cut out the post to save space>>> Great post. I'm a proponent of the Audrey in the lodge theory, and your observations really back it up. The paneling/door is a dead giveaway, imo. Love the TS Eliot connection too. I knew I didn't need to freeze frame that bookshelf myself. Good work! There are ...

djsunyc wrote:question - does norma still have super strength? if so, she could be a valuable asset to the black lodge if the woodsmen are able to get to her via jacoby's airwaves.

Norma never had super strength, Nadine did. Perhaps she can take out a few woodsmen when needed. Particularly if Ed is in danger.