My apologies... I type most of this from an iPad now, and can't figure out how to quote multiple people, or anything complicated beyond a normal post here. Even with the Audrey scene out of the equation, I'm surprised by how critical people are with this installment, as if it were vastly different ...

Just an opinion - not super insightful or anything just from a general fan/viewer - I very rarely post, but I was motivated to chime in: After last week's episode being the best so far, this one really pissed me off. I'm a big fan, but not someone who completely worships David Lynch, so I am disapp...

tbh the audrey scene kinda grew on me. the Audrey scene was fine, it makes total sense that some things 25 years later are bafflingly different. It cant all be Andy & Lucy. The ending of the scene was funny, as if Lynch was saying "he he Im not going to explain for you" The problem wa...

wAtChLaR wrote:

nick1218 wrote:

its not even top 5 of Lynch films

wait...what?

did I stutter

I think when we all heard Lynch was directing it all it sounded too good to be true. We expected a full season filled with episodes like Episode 14 and Episode 29. But instead we're mostly getting the weaker parts of "Mulholland Drive", in my opinion. Mulholland Drive doesn't have any wea...

I'm seeing a lot of comments that people pointing out that this is intentional shaggy-dog storytelling are "justifying" or just can't admit Lynch can make a mistake. I'm sorry, but that's nonsense. I certainly can't blame people for not liking it... I mean it wouldn't be fulfilling it's p...

Jesus, I'm amazed at some people's incapacity to connect the dots. It's all layed down before your eyes, people. Twin Peaks : The Return is NOT the continuation of the original Twin Peaks. Lynch's intention is to tell a whole other story. The main theme is the desintegration of the word. The whole ...

So was Ben worried when Frank mentioned they were looking into some old cases related to Agent Cooper that it might be bad for him. Ben likely doesn't know anything about Agent Cooper have "disappeared". He may think that old cases could relate to him (i.e. One-Eyed Jacks, Jean Renault, e...

Esselgee wrote:Did anyone else think that it was going to be Jean-Michel Renault in the hospital bed at first?

Is that the first we've seen inside the Twin Peaks hospital this season? There were many scenes there during the original series, of course.

haha, yes I did

This was the first time in The Return that I've found it a chore to finish a part. It just didn't gel for me. It felt like mostly leftovers, filler and repurposed footage. I did love Diane entering through the red curtains, Carl's display of kindness and his advice against selling blood, Cole's new...

I personally thought the French woman was hilarious, her acting was just perfectly over the top. Kind of surprised though that the womanizer theme for Cole is so central. why is a woman like that in south dakota? lol I dont know but when I get in my 70s and have a giant hearing aid at least I know ...

Not the best episode but not bad. Red curtains in the hotel room, that's a nice touch. Sarah Palmer is great and creepy. "Men are coming" are probably certain "dirty bearded men in a room". What was that in her kitchen? And the fan.. I liked Audrey. I don't know what people were...

Just finished watching, and I'm glad I had my expectations lowered by the chat window this morning. and went in just expecting a regular episode. It was great! I loved, loved, loved the return of the backwards FWWM sound design, and the Sarah Palmer stuff was amazing. I was laughing throughout the ...

What??????? If it makes you ask, "I wonder where they're going next with this?", that's pretty much the posted definition of "cliffhanger". Look it up on dictionary.com! http://www.dictionary.com/browse/cliffhanger?s=t The term dates back to the movie serials before there were T...

All speculation and some worrying about how Lynch can tie everything or most things up begs the question, will there be a fourth season? I remember someone asked Lynch during the making of this season if there will be a continuation? Lynch said something along the line we will see. Would've loved f...