Lynch appears to be in fine health, physically and mentally. He's a celebrated artist and is free from many of the struggles people like you and I endure on a daily basis just to survive. Yet sometimes our emotional state doesn't reflect our reality, so there's that too. That last sentence could se...

The more I think about it, it’s not SO egregious, maybe. The pages we see Leland tear out in FWWM are presumably the pages Hawk finds by the train car. At some point later, Leland discovers where there diary is by following Laura and goes back, perhaps even after Laura’s death, to make sure his trac...

The Harold/diary thing has been a mess since FWWM, where Laura implies she is leaving her diary with him never to see it again, despite Episode 16 showing diary entries written 2/22 and 2/24. You’re right, it’s even more problematic that apparently two of the four pages torn out by Leland/Bob were w...

Nope, as a matter of fact there are 6 mentions of the word "lodge" in TPS3. Do you have a transcript of the show? Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk These are the best I’ve found: https://www.springfieldspringfield.co.uk/episode_scripts.php?tv-show=twin-peaks It’s just the spoken dialogue (...

Thoughts on the interview: Interesting that DKL seems to endorse Jacoby’s viewpoint to some extent. L/F’s feelings on Jacoby are really fascinating to me. I initially thought both were satirizing the Alex Jones type of media personality/conspiracy theorist, albeit with more a liberal slant that refl...

Wow! So THAT was the much-talked-about in-point that gave them both a way in to the story? L/F work in mysterious ways.

I’m glad they kept the Fireman solely in B&W. It would have been weird to have one random shot of him in color. I wonder if DKL was trying to get coverage of flesh and blood actors delivering EotA’s most important lines just in case he couldn’t come up with a CGI design he was happy with.

The White and Black Lodge mythology is rather interesting to think about, as Mark Frost borrowed the concept from Dion Fortune’s Psychic Self-Defense and introduced it into TP mythology in the back half of season 2. Originally a black and white version of the Great Northern was going to be the Blac...

I’d theorized that the Fireman’s might be the White Lodge (mostly due to the gold pool which, as noted, seems like the exact opposite of the oil pool), but I also suspected that it probably wasn’t that simple. It sounds like DKL may have found the challenge that entices him back to TP.

Diane wrote:When Cooper leaves the lodge it seems they are in the past, maybe the 60's (judging from the old car and the motel), until they cross the 430 line and everything changes.

There is a TV in the motel room that is at least ‘80s-era

Good point on the repeated footage from Episode 29. Definite food for thought.

"Look, Richard, these items belonged to your poor mother you've never known... her impressive collection of stunning knitwear... an earmarked copy of The scarlet letter... unopened math textbooks... a photo of that guy she crushed on for like two weeks..." I find it really hard to believe...

I am sorry, but I can only speak on behalf of my own thinking and not, like you, according to what Lynch (DKL) had in mind. Fair enough. Certainly we’re not mind readers, and DKL’s process is about as elusive as any artist’s. But for me, it seems a logical inference. I think many other fans on thes...

I agree that American Girl is a separate character from Ronette, but there’s not a doubt in my mind that DKL chose her for the role to evoke Ronette in the audience’s mind, not just at random (as opposed to, say, the reuse of Matt Battaglia or Bellina Logan, which were probably just because DKL want...

For years (probably since the Pilot aired), fans have theorized that Diane is a construct of Dale’s imagination to help him think out loud (or was possibly the name of his tape recorder). I think TP:TR is absolutely having fun with that theory to some extent. As with so many aspects of this show, it...