Na, not a supernatural event. Just a beautiful stylistic flair that emphasizes Laura's pain and suggesting that her spirit is in some kind of limbo. I don't think it "happened" diegetically (in the world of the story). I agree that most likely when it was filmed it was meant as a (beautif...

Yesterday I re-watched S1E2 for the first time after the Return’s finale. One scene that previously escaped me is the slow motion video of Laura and Donna’s picnic, I believe with a toned down piano version of Laura’s theme - not dissimilar to Heartbreaking in the famous restaurant scene. At the end...

Xavi wrote:Nope, as a matter of fact there are 6 mentions of the word "lodge" in TPS3.

Do you have a transcript of the show?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Wait, wait... Andy moves the chair?!? Really? I totally missed it! Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Yes! Moves the chair into position so Mr. C can sit down. Watch him do it. It's very interesting. Ok, you caused me to re-watch good portions of 17 and 18, which means my wife’s rolling her eyes and ...

While it has crossed my mind that Andy’s “very important” conveyed the mental image to Lucy, it seems to function on a more literal level as Andy pointing at the phone, indicating that the call which is about to come in is very important. Lucy even repeats the words when Frank tells her to take a m...

It's definitely tragicomic, good word! In and of itself and especially in response to those who have a problem with his lack of forward progression, I've frequently noted the existential irony in his goal, the achievement of which instantly leads to his doom. It's certainly funny. I think that “lac...

Another thing to consider is what happens if/when Mr. C. dies. Does Bob need to return to the Lodge? It seems like he has the freedom to roam around the Earth looking for a host when not inhabiting anyone. If Bob does need to return though, then Fireman's and Judy's goal might be one and the same i...

I now really think that the conversation is that last thing (chronologically) that we see in the series. Cooper is very far away. He is asked to remember Richard and Linda from his past. i.e. this scene somehow shows us a future Cooper in peril being guided by the Fireman to get out of it. I think ...

To that end, why did Cooper and Diane travel to another reality? They knew things could be very different where they were going, but had no control over what would happen. It seems like a huge risk. Cooper had already prevented Laura from dying in 1989. This should have become a retroactive change ...

First, I get that Cooper knew what he was trying to do - changing the past, which would result in things being different - but I don't know that we can take that Odessa world to mean that it changed in the ways he meant to change it. To that end, why did Cooper and Diane travel to another reality? ...

While it has crossed my mind that Andy’s “very important” conveyed the mental image to Lucy, it seems to function on a more literal level as Andy pointing at the phone, indicating that the call which is about to come in is very important. Lucy even repeats the words when Frank tells her to take a m...

Not necessarily. The Fireman might also show danger, that is show the consequences of actions that should NOT be taken. As a matter of fact, the Fireman shows Andy at least one thing that never takes place. The “Andy positioning Lucy” thing is weird/interesting. I’m trying to remember the exact seq...

Everything he did followed the Fireman's advice. Major Briggs knew they'd be at the Sheriff station and he wanted Coop to get the key to the Great Northern boiler room. Andy was shown a vision of the telegraph pole outside Carrie's house in Odessa. If he failed, it's because he was considered expen...

I was watching the famous phone call. The voice says: “I just called to say goodbye”...”You are going back in tomorrow, and I will be with Bob again.” Now, according to what we know Mr.C does NOT want to be back, he actually prevents it. If Mr.C just wanted to be with Judy he simply had to... go ba...

I was watching the famous phone call. The voice says: “I just called to say goodbye”...”You are going back in tomorrow, and I will be with Bob again.” Now, according to what we know Mr.C does NOT want to be back, he actually prevents it. If Mr.C just wanted to be with Judy he simply had to... go bac...