Page 2 of 8

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Thu May 25, 2017 11:23 pm
by TheAlien
I am actually not dreading anything, in fact; for once with a show, I have complete faith in whatever David makes of it :mrgreen:

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 12:00 am
by Melong
Thatfabulousalien wrote:I am actually not dreading anything, in fact; for once with a show, I have complete faith in whatever David makes of it :mrgreen:
This. :)

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 2:23 am
by Panapaok
I feel that there will be a happy ending after all the darkness. Similar to Blue Velvet. The only thing I don't want is another cliffhanger. Bring us some closure, whatever it is.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 9:10 am
by AnotherBlueRoseCase
MoondogJR wrote:"it was all a dream"

However, I think I could make peace with that, now that I think of it...
If S03 is indeed a Wizard of Oz homage you may be on the button there.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 10:14 am
by bowisneski
I don't actually dread endings in general because I am more interested in the journey than the final destination, at least with television. I feel a movie ending being bad has a much larger chance of ruining an experience than does a show. Longform television and storytelling, to me, feels like a roadtrip where the trip itself is the point and not the specific location you end up in, while a movie feels more like a journey to and spending time at the destination. Sure that location can enhance or detract from the trip but it can almost never ruin the entire trip.

However, thinking about possibilities that would leave me dissatisfied are possible. The worst offender would be it was all a dream. Sure, it wouldn't ruin what the experience has been but it would put a damper on me ever wanting to rewatch or engage with this story again, outside of being a beautiful piece of visual art. Dreams can, and in this case should, be part of the journey because they reveal things to us and the characters. But if it was all a dream it would remove any care for these characters upon rewatch because their stories and lives don't matter outside of the dream the dreamer was having. This only applies to the it was all a dream ending though. If Coop just wakes up somewhere in episodes 5 - 17 and we find out everything before was a dream, but we get to see the character move forward and progress with the knowledge and insight gained from the dream it wouldn't bother me.

Other than that, I dread a simple ending or one that provides too much closure. One that doesn't stay with you. Knowing Lynch in general, this is probably a fear I shouldn't have but it's still in the back of my mind.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 10:16 am
by sylviecerise
Panapaok wrote:I feel that there will be a happy ending after all the darkness. Similar to Blue Velvet. The only thing I don't want is another cliffhanger. Bring us some closure, whatever it is.
I want an unresolved ending!! Or something a little open. The cliffhanger at the end of S2 aided in fandom obsession & analyzing. Maybe not something quite as sinister and foreboding, but an ending that allows us room to think forward and not just set aside Twin Peaks.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 11:59 am
by Mr. Reindeer
I'm pretty much fine with anything DKL does, he hasn't let me down yet. However, I am sort of hoping it's not the Wizard of Oz tribute that one website was theorizing. DKL loves that movie, I do too, but it's a cliché. The Wizard of Oz stuff in W@H is the weakest part of the movie for me, would prefer for TP:TR to do something less predictable.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 2:27 pm
by mtwentz
Mr. Reindeer wrote:I'm pretty much fine with anything DKL does, he hasn't let me down yet. However, I am sort of hoping it's not the Wizard of Oz tribute that one website was theorizing. DKL loves that movie, I do too, but it's a cliché. The Wizard of Oz stuff in W@H is the weakest part of the movie for me, would prefer for TP:TR to do something less predictable.
Yeah I was going to say, 'Been there, done that' in Wild At Heart. If anything, it looks like a tribute to Alice In Wonderland more than anything (down the old rabbit hole).

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 2:35 pm
by Soolsma
Concerning endings;

Take the original Cooper dream and regard that as the tip of the iceberg of the originals. See how that amounts to episode 29.
Now take all the crazy stuff we've seen so far and think of it as the tip of another iceberg.

Imagine the finale of season 3.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 2:45 pm
by mtwentz
Soolsma wrote:Concerning endings;

Take the original Cooper dream and regard that as the tip of the iceberg of the originals. See how that amounts to episode 29.
Now take all the crazy stuff we've seen so far and think of it as the tip of another iceberg.

Imagine the finale of season 3.
I know what you mean Soolsma- I feel my mind has already been blown out of my head. And there are 14 hours left!

I feel a little burnt right now- what an emotional rollercoaster it's been since the day Lynch and Frost tweeted the gum was coming back in style. This last week has been fabulous and I've been all over this board, but I think I am going to (try) and stay off dugpa for the weekend, and get back on around Tuesday.

So if you see me even lurking the board the next 3 days, feel free to call me out on it :-).

Have a great weekend.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 3:43 pm
by Harry Yallrite
Dale Cooper is entrusted to take over as the new MIKE when the Arm/Tree Doppelgänger extinguishes his spirit

Phillip Jeffries takes the place of BOB when DoppelCoop is murdered in the real world and BOB cannot escape his body.

Cooper vs. Jeffries battle for control of the Black Lodge that - when Coop wins by extinguishing the spirit/soul of Jeffries/BOB - transforms into the WHITE LODGE for ever more.

Cooper cuts his RIGHT arm off and it transforms into a talking tape recorder that says "I... AM... THE... ARM. CALL... ME... DIANE."

Cut to BLACK

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 5:40 pm
by derekfnord
Dale starts awake from a dream, in bed with Suzanne Pleshette...

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 6:48 pm
by asselta
Harry Yallrite wrote:Dale Cooper is entrusted to take over as the new MIKE when the Arm/Tree Doppelgänger extinguishes his spirit

Cooper cuts his RIGHT arm off and it transforms into a talking tape recorder that says "I... AM... THE... ARM. CALL... ME... DIANE."

Cut to BLACK
Pure gold.

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 7:09 pm
by TheAlien
Harry Yallrite wrote:Cooper cuts his RIGHT arm off and it transforms into a talking tape recorder that says "I... AM... THE... ARM. CALL... ME... DIANE."

Cut to BLACK
Dale Cooper gets stabbed to death once and for all by the mystery man (from LH), the camera is drawn back to reveal the Lost Girl (from IE) watching the ending of Twin Peaks S3 and crying. She turns around, the camera then pans around we briefly see the baby from Eraserhead laying on the same bed. Then David Lynch's voice is heard:

"And CUT!. Karolina, we need more energy, more enthusiasm. Think about Frank Booth for a moment, what kind of terror does his character make you feel? try and incorporate those emotions to your reaction to Twin Peaks"

"Ok David, I'll try"

"Hey Mark (Frost), can you ask someone to get me some water, the shooting today is killing me"

"Sure David"

Re: S3: Make Your Peace Now with the Ending You Dread (SPOILERS)

Posted: Mon May 29, 2017 11:04 am
by Elad Repooc
It's already done, so all we can do is go along for the wild ride.

As for a prediction of how I think it might end, I think it might end both open and closed. I think the Cooper story will have closure, but there will be something else left open. I think that would be ideal. It would mean it would feel okay if they decided not to make another season, but also okay if they did.