The White Horse Represents Denial
Posted: Wed Sep 06, 2017 5:36 pm
Before Fire Walk With Me, it would be anybody's guess whether or not Sarah was in denial or not about the abuse that had taken place. But that movie makes a pretty strong case for the fact that some part of her always knew, but she was unable to accept it, the white horse is a metaphor for this. While time is relative in the lodges, it is a fair assumption to say that in terms of the timeline the very first scene we can place in it is Cooper sitting in the chair, with MIKE next to him asking that question "Is it future or is it past?" this is where the story begins in The Return, at least for Dale Cooper. This is 25 years later - Starting position.
In Part 2 Laura shows up after MIKE asks him that very question, she then gets up and whispers something in Coopers ear, he looks distraught and she is pulled out of the lodge. Now the curtains blow away to reveal a white horse, Cooper stares at it and we fly into the abyss and we're back at starting position. MIKE asking the question "Is it future, or is it past?"
Jump forward 16 episodes and we're back to this very moment. Laura has just gotten pulled away from Dale in the woods after his attempt to alter the past. He finds himself in the lodge with MIKE again. "Is it future or is it past?" they both get up to meet The Arm and Cooper is asked "Is it the story about the little girl on the lane? is it?" suddenly he remembers what Laura whispered to him, and he finds himself back in that chair, this time however the curtains do not blow away to reveal a horse. He gets up and leaves the lodge, fully conscious of what he's been told.
In the end, Dale wasn't successful, there was nothing he could do to undo what happened to her and he finds himself back in that chair, Laura whispering into his ear what he isn't ready to accept. Part 2 was Dale entering the story in denial, and he came out as Dougie. Part 18 is him entering the story without it, yet he still manages to repeat the same mistake. Stuck in a loop.
side note: Carrie Paige has repressed her whole existence and this is driven home again by the white horse in her house, and the horse-shoe necklace.
In Part 2 Laura shows up after MIKE asks him that very question, she then gets up and whispers something in Coopers ear, he looks distraught and she is pulled out of the lodge. Now the curtains blow away to reveal a white horse, Cooper stares at it and we fly into the abyss and we're back at starting position. MIKE asking the question "Is it future, or is it past?"
Jump forward 16 episodes and we're back to this very moment. Laura has just gotten pulled away from Dale in the woods after his attempt to alter the past. He finds himself in the lodge with MIKE again. "Is it future or is it past?" they both get up to meet The Arm and Cooper is asked "Is it the story about the little girl on the lane? is it?" suddenly he remembers what Laura whispered to him, and he finds himself back in that chair, this time however the curtains do not blow away to reveal a horse. He gets up and leaves the lodge, fully conscious of what he's been told.
In the end, Dale wasn't successful, there was nothing he could do to undo what happened to her and he finds himself back in that chair, Laura whispering into his ear what he isn't ready to accept. Part 2 was Dale entering the story in denial, and he came out as Dougie. Part 18 is him entering the story without it, yet he still manages to repeat the same mistake. Stuck in a loop.
side note: Carrie Paige has repressed her whole existence and this is driven home again by the white horse in her house, and the horse-shoe necklace.