And what's really sad is that this might be because Ben is on the straight and narrow now. One thing we've seen repeatedly with the Horne storyline is that they are lost, injured, and endangered and Ben hasn't helped when they've called. Jerry is having a terrible trip and has been lost in the woods for DAYS by now, and the first person he called was Ben. Ben couldn't even understand him. Johnnie injured himself in the house, the house that is not the Great Northern, now that he seems to only be under his mother's care. Before, he did have servants and a psychologist on call to help with Johnnie. Sylvia even brings up Ben when Richard assaults her, she says "Why don't you ask your Grandfather? Because he won't give you any any more," showing that Ben is the remaining wall against Richard, but when Sylvia calls Ben all that happens is bickering and Ben's next move is to try and relieve his stress rather than rein in his grandson. And Audrey, who USED to be the rebel, is god knows where. But back in the original series, when Audrey was in trouble Ben was able to get Cooper to rescue her.mtwentz wrote:I think that's one thing we can all agree on: Richard is a bastard. Figuratively and probably literally too!Ragnell wrote:asmahan wrote:What is it about this particularepisode that somehow crosses the line though??? Seriously? Miriam's death wasn't handled in a particularly gratuitous manner, the Stephen/Becky scene was also not graphic, very brief and was meant to garner sympathy for Becky... Nothing remotely as violent as Spike's hit on Lorraine, for example. Undeniably, it's valid to analyze the gender politics of the series, whether or not Lynch/Frost are trying to "say something". Personally, I don't believe any of the scenes so far have been genuinely exploitative or gratuitous.
Honestly, I didn't think so either. For me the introduction of Richard and him threatening that girl was the most upsetting scene when it came to women. But I think, for a lot of people, the line was Sylvia. Sylvia is an older woman, Richard's GRANDMOTHER, and he chokes her, yells at her, threatens her son, steals from her, and calls her the C-word. That's abusing a woman, abusing an elder, a step above abusing his mother, terrorizing her, and using foul gendered language. That scene is like a checklist of terrifying, abusive things and I can see how it was too much for some people. Especially when its preceded by introducing Sylvia as the caregiver for a now-injured son, and followed by that conversation with Ben that establishes she's a) divorced, and b) Ben is apparently (APPARENTLY, because maybe his ethics break will include being willing to use his influence to take measures against Richard now?) not able or willing to defend her.
All of this with the added trauma of watching poor Johnnie witness this, try desperately to help his mother and be restrained from it. (Which may be a metaphor for how the whole town, including Ben, is restrained by ethics, fear, or corrupt interference from stopping Richard.)
And it's Richard. We already saw Richard attack a woman and leave her for dead this ep. (And I was grateful we didn't actually see him attack Miriam in the trailer). Previously we've seen Richard threaten rape on two girls in the roadhouse, and run a young child over in the street. It's a distinct possibility that Richard is the result of the season villain raping the most popular female character on the show. We learned he has Chad interfering with attempts to bring him to justice.
Richard is just an upsetting character, and this was his most upsetting scene. This was the most upsetting scene in the ep for me (Johnnie put it over the top there.) I don't want just anyone to get Richard. I want COOPER to get Richard now.
Because Richard is a bully. Richard is afraid of Red, Richard is paying off the cops to keep the good guys off his tail, but Richard violently terrorizes, assaults, threatens, and kills woman, children, the elderly, and the disabled even if they are in his own family. And one of the reasons I love Cooper is he is immune to bullies, and disgusted by guys like Richard.
*Ahem* But anyway. Richard's basically a character that embodies the horror of misogyny, domestic abuse, and small scale tyranny. He's a wild, rich bully with no empathy. He probably tortured animals as a child. In a scene with violence against a woman, the effect is amplified when the perpetrator is a guy like Richard because you know the motive is he's trying to secure his own power by robbing that woman of hers. It's perfectly understandable that people find that upsetting, and that it may seem gratuitous since so far Richard isn't really involved or connected to the main Cooper plot. (Except, of course, by his first name and the possibility that the most popular female character from the original series was raped. Which is just more upsetting.)
In the original series, Ben had a dysfunctional family, but they were all under the same roof and he managed to provide and care for them all with his shadiness. Now Ben's managed to become a good, honest man, but his family is scattered and he's unable to protect them. He's unable to reign in the new family rebel, who has become a thousand times worse than Audrey ever had the potential to be.
I suspect, thinking about it, that whatever end comes to Richard may be initiated by Ben somehow. Maybe Ben calls Audrey back from wherever and she managed to put an end to Richard's behavior. Or Ben reopens his underworld connections or finally uses some of the good guy connections he has. Bobby Briggs used to work for Ben, that's a string to pull at the Sheriff's office. Maybe when Cooper gets to Twin Peaks, Ben offers to waive some of the price of the room if he ferrets out whichever deputy is covering for Richard.
Either way, Richard seems to have come about because the head of the family lost his influence over them, and has let them scatter. I'm getting the impression fatherhood is a big theme this season, the need for good, attentive fatherhood rather than the corrupt fatherhood we saw all over the original series. Frank Truman having lost his son. Major Briggs having faith in Bobby and the foresight to prepare him. Dale vs Dougie as a father. I think that the Horne plotline ties into this, showing Ben hasn't truly straightened out because he's put his personal ethics together but allowed his family to fall apart.