Tarantino criticism
Moderators: Brad D, Annie, Jonah, BookhouseBoyBob, Ross, Jerry Horne
Tarantino criticism
I just got back from "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood".
After Fire Walk With Me premiered, the then hot shot new kid on the block had this to say about the film and Lynch: "“David Lynch had disappeared so far up his own ass that I have no desire to see another David Lynch movie until I hear something different.”
My lord does someone need to throw that one right back at Tarantino. It was never a fair comment about Lynch or FWWM.... and it couldn't be a more apt criticism for Tarantino's latest string of work, dating back at least a decade. Unfortunately Tarantino is overrated and critics and film nerds kiss his ass. But, as FWWM's reputation has soared as it has aged, I really question whether Tarantino's latest films will stand the test of time. Someone's going to have to explain to me what the cultural value is in narcissistic gonzo revisions of real life tragedy and trauma.
After Fire Walk With Me premiered, the then hot shot new kid on the block had this to say about the film and Lynch: "“David Lynch had disappeared so far up his own ass that I have no desire to see another David Lynch movie until I hear something different.”
My lord does someone need to throw that one right back at Tarantino. It was never a fair comment about Lynch or FWWM.... and it couldn't be a more apt criticism for Tarantino's latest string of work, dating back at least a decade. Unfortunately Tarantino is overrated and critics and film nerds kiss his ass. But, as FWWM's reputation has soared as it has aged, I really question whether Tarantino's latest films will stand the test of time. Someone's going to have to explain to me what the cultural value is in narcissistic gonzo revisions of real life tragedy and trauma.
Re: Tarantino criticism
Tarantino is like Lynch in that neither director has made a truly 'bad' film in their career.AgentEcho wrote:I just got back from "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood".
After Fire Walk With Me premiered, the then hot shot new kid on the block had this to say about the film and Lynch: "“David Lynch had disappeared so far up his own ass that I have no desire to see another David Lynch movie until I hear something different.”
My lord does someone need to throw that one right back at Tarantino. It was never a fair comment about Lynch or FWWM.... and it couldn't be a more apt criticism for Tarantino's latest string of work, dating back at least a decade. Unfortunately Tarantino is overrated and critics and film nerds kiss his ass. But, as FWWM's reputation has soared as it has aged, I really question whether Tarantino's latest films will stand the test of time. Someone's going to have to explain to me what the cultural value is in narcissistic gonzo revisions of real life tragedy and trauma.
I haven't seen Once Upon A Time in Hollywood, but as of now, it has a Rotten Tomatoes score of 84%. On an objective scale, it's a critical success. I'll wait until I see it to make my own judgment, but it looks like Tarantino has scored another hit.
As far as Tarantino being overrated, I kind of agree with you, but we can't deny he has reached a level of success commercially that no other filmmaker in our time has achieved. But to compare Tarantino and Lynch is a little tough- there are similarities in the films they make, but Tarantino is obviously more for the mainstream, while Lynch is more an art house movie director. But they've both pushed the boundaries and influenced the industry, so in that way they are similar.
I just think Tarantino didn't 'get' what Lynch was going for in FWWM.
F*&^ you Gene Kelly
Re: Tarantino criticism
It's fine to not "get" FWWM, but the comment was disrespectful at a minimum, and I think it would be fitting for this one to come home to roost for Tarantino. (It won't because he's a critics darling)
Naturally since I feel he's overrated, I don't think the good rotten tomatoes score really proves anything. And I should say I did and still like his work from the first part of his career. I particularly like Jackie Brown, which is oddly his most unheralded film.
I don't know how appropriate it is to go into detail about why I've found his work for about the past dozen years to be a trajectory of disappearing up his own ass, given not everyone has seen those films and especially OUaTiH which was just released, but I found the irony of his criticism of Lynch being something I'd say is more fair to level at him at this stage in his career too much not to comment on.
Naturally since I feel he's overrated, I don't think the good rotten tomatoes score really proves anything. And I should say I did and still like his work from the first part of his career. I particularly like Jackie Brown, which is oddly his most unheralded film.
I don't know how appropriate it is to go into detail about why I've found his work for about the past dozen years to be a trajectory of disappearing up his own ass, given not everyone has seen those films and especially OUaTiH which was just released, but I found the irony of his criticism of Lynch being something I'd say is more fair to level at him at this stage in his career too much not to comment on.
Re: Tarantino criticism
I was going to go and see Once Upon A Time In Hollywood UNTIL I read that Tarantino said this about Lynch and then I decided to not support him. I have never cared either way for his films but a few are alright, he is nothing original and I can't believe that he of all people had the nerve to say this comment about David Lynch.
David Lynch is far superior to him.
David Lynch is far superior to him.
Re: Tarantino criticism
I can never separate Tarantino's films from his obnoxious personality. I once went to a screening of that Grindhouse film he did (with the long car chase), followed by a Q&A. Dunno why, since I never really cared for his films. He gave his typical "I'm a genius" answers, including how the ability to write the amazing dialogue in his films is "his gift".
Everyone in all of his films talks exactly the same way! The same very stylised crap dialogue that is meant to be post-modern and witty, but is actually just dumb, and it tells you nothing about the human condition.
Watch an Eric Rohmer film if you want good dialogue.
You may have realised that I have never seen why Tarantino gets worshipped so much. His films seemed to define some concept of "cool" for an entire generation in the 90s, and they all put the shitty songs from his shitty soundtracks on my pub jukebox all the shitty time, and it really wound me up. "I'm cool because I just put on a song from a film which a newspaper said was really cool!". Arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh.
(Apologies if you actually like his films- I'm being a bit aggressive for no reason)
Everyone in all of his films talks exactly the same way! The same very stylised crap dialogue that is meant to be post-modern and witty, but is actually just dumb, and it tells you nothing about the human condition.
Watch an Eric Rohmer film if you want good dialogue.
You may have realised that I have never seen why Tarantino gets worshipped so much. His films seemed to define some concept of "cool" for an entire generation in the 90s, and they all put the shitty songs from his shitty soundtracks on my pub jukebox all the shitty time, and it really wound me up. "I'm cool because I just put on a song from a film which a newspaper said was really cool!". Arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh.
(Apologies if you actually like his films- I'm being a bit aggressive for no reason)
Re: Tarantino criticism
Big Tarantino fan here but I’ve no problem with the criticism. I love both Lynch and Tarantino as each have a distinct personality that is uniquely their own and the reason I see all their films. I don’t expect them to like each other as long as they keep making movies.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Robot Novelist: http://tevanbuskirk.wordpress.com/
-
- Bookhouse Member
- Posts: 1173
- Joined: Sat Jan 14, 2017 12:55 am
Re: Tarantino criticism
100% in agreement with Leo K! Both are great filmmakers, I hope they get to create more content which I can enjoy the hell out of. As it is, I haven't had this experience with Lynch's products since The Straight Story, as much as that depresses me...
Re: Tarantino criticism
I can absolutely see that Tarantino is a proper auteur with a unique style. I've just never clicked with it. Maybe I should revisit his early work and see if I can get into it. I've never seen the Lynch comparisons either. Wild at Heart is the only film that to me has any similarity with a Tarantino film, and that's only because it has graphic violence. Directors from that period who share much more with Lynch (to my eye at least) are Atom Egoyan and Gregg Araki (particularly The Doom Generation).
Now the reasons I hate Tarantino are also the reasons I love Lynch! He has a unique style, his dialogue is very stylised, and his films contain shocking moments. So I'm a massive hypocrite basically. Or there is just something in the mood and vibe of a Tarantino film that I find boring.
It might simply be a case of me not liking something because I knew annoying people who loved it. c.f. fans of Oasis in the 1990s. I like the band in retrospect.
Now the reasons I hate Tarantino are also the reasons I love Lynch! He has a unique style, his dialogue is very stylised, and his films contain shocking moments. So I'm a massive hypocrite basically. Or there is just something in the mood and vibe of a Tarantino film that I find boring.
It might simply be a case of me not liking something because I knew annoying people who loved it. c.f. fans of Oasis in the 1990s. I like the band in retrospect.
Re: Tarantino criticism
Whether one thinks he's the best director of all time, or a two hit wonder (Reservoir and Pulp) who's parlayed initial success into puffing up his reputation beyond what it deserves, I think most of us agree it's in poor taste for Tarantino to boost his own standing by attempting to disparage the works of others (Lynch was not the only director Tarantino criticized).
I hope he's grown up since that 1992 interview.
I hope he's grown up since that 1992 interview.
F*&^ you Gene Kelly
- N. Needleman
- Lodge Member
- Posts: 2113
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2014 2:39 pm
Re: Tarantino criticism
At that time it was all the rage for everyone to shit on FWWM and Twin Peaks. I would like to believe QT has revised his opinion.
I am a big, big fan of Jackie Brown, Inglourious Basterds etc. and I liked OUAT quite a lot. A very lyrical, quieter film for him, and a brave departure for a man who could've simply catered to an audience used to wall to wall dialogue and violence.
I am a big, big fan of Jackie Brown, Inglourious Basterds etc. and I liked OUAT quite a lot. A very lyrical, quieter film for him, and a brave departure for a man who could've simply catered to an audience used to wall to wall dialogue and violence.
AnotherBlueRoseCase wrote:The Return is clearly guaranteed a future audience among stoners and other drug users.
- bowisneski
- RR Diner Member
- Posts: 239
- Joined: Fri Oct 14, 2016 11:51 am
Re: Tarantino criticism
I've always felt that was a shitty and hypocritical thing for him to say because he and Lynch are both far up their own asses in the sense that they make what they want without a care for the how the world will feel about it. Something that I think is freaking great and how every director should approach their work.
I was wary about Once Upon a Time in Hollywood because of the premise and I was but I ended up loving it. It had the feeling of Season 3 and Blade Runner 2049 where it is unapologetically what it is, luxuriates in mood, and is beautiful.
I was wary about Once Upon a Time in Hollywood because of the premise and I was
Spoiler:
- Rainwater
- RR Diner Member
- Posts: 399
- Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 3:00 am
- Location: Under the Sycamore trees
Re: Tarantino criticism
I was never a big fan, he's obviously a talented filmmaker, but to me his talent is wasted on his sensibilities which don't match mine at all. I have enjoyed parts of his work before, but my favorite movie "of his" is one he only wrote, True Romance(which, I suspect, he would've ruined, had he directed it himself which almost happened). That being said, the above comments do make me want to check out Once Upon a Time.
I'll see you in the trees
Re: Tarantino criticism
Was it just me, or did the coffee scene in Pulp Fiction "The Bonnie Situation" seem heavily influenced by Twin Peaks?
F*&^ you Gene Kelly
Re: Tarantino criticism
I'd largely agree with this take, in that it is clear he is talented... his movies usually engaging, but especially with his most recent work, I'm not jiving with what he's trying to do. I'd split his career into two eras: the "contemporary crime film era" spanning from Reservoir Dogs to Kill Bill (or maybe his "Grindhouse" segment) and the "historical fantasy" era from Inglorious Basterds to the present. I did really like a lot of the contemporary crime films, with Jackie Brown being my favorite. It's been the historical fantasy era where my appreciation for his films have been sliding downwards. OUTH has all the same issues I have with the other films of that era, though it is indeed for the most part, a quieter film than the rest.Rainwater wrote:I was never a big fan, he's obviously a talented filmmaker, but to me his talent is wasted on his sensibilities which don't match mine at all. I have enjoyed parts of his work before, but my favorite movie "of his" is one he only wrote, True Romance(which, I suspect, he would've ruined, had he directed it himself which almost happened). That being said, the above comments do make me want to check out Once Upon a Time.
I'm sure there are folks who really jive with Tarantino and think Lynch is incoherent and pretentious... but had Lynch gone out of his way to trash Tarantino or another's work, I'd expect his critics to have a field day with it.
Re: Tarantino criticism
I had a similar reaction to Once Upon A Time... Within the context of the film itself, I don't really know what the point is inAgentEcho wrote:Someone's going to have to explain to me what the cultural value is in narcissistic gonzo revisions of real life tragedy and trauma.
Spoiler: